diff --git a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/category/component/unit-mapping.tsx b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/category/component/unit-mapping.tsx
index 109583ed..34509901 100644
--- a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/category/component/unit-mapping.tsx
+++ b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/category/component/unit-mapping.tsx
@@ -150,11 +150,11 @@ export function UnitMapping(props: {
                                   onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                                     return checked
                                       ? field.onChange([
-                                          ...field.value,
+                                          ...(field.value ?? []),
                                           String(item.id),
                                         ])
                                       : field.onChange(
-                                          field.value?.filter(
+                                          (field.value ?? []).filter(
                                             (value) => value !== String(item.id)
                                           )
                                         );
@@ -223,11 +223,11 @@ export function UnitMapping(props: {
                                   onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                                     return checked
                                       ? field.onChange([
-                                          ...field.value,
+                                          ...(field.value ?? []),
                                           String(item.id),
                                         ])
                                       : field.onChange(
-                                          field.value?.filter(
+                                          (field.value ?? []).filter(
                                             (value) => value !== String(item.id)
                                           )
                                         );
diff --git a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/detail.tsx b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/detail.tsx
index 83fdd0dc..882ba90b 100644
--- a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/detail.tsx
+++ b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/detail.tsx
@@ -98,11 +98,11 @@ export default function DetailSettingTracking(props: {
                     {wilayahList.map((item) => (
                       <div key={item.id} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(item.id)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(item.id) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, item.id]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== item.id);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), item.id]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== item.id);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
@@ -124,11 +124,11 @@ export default function DetailSettingTracking(props: {
                     {jumlahList.map((num) => (
                       <div key={num} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(num)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(num) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, num]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== num);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), num]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== num);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
diff --git a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/update.tsx b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/update.tsx
index 0e77a95c..2c2039e9 100644
--- a/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/update.tsx
+++ b/app/[locale]/(protected)/admin/settings/setting-tracking/component/update.tsx
@@ -98,11 +98,11 @@ export default function UpdateSettingTracking(props: {
                     {wilayahList.map((item) => (
                       <div key={item.id} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(item.id)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(item.id) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, item.id]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== item.id);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), item.id]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== item.id);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
@@ -124,11 +124,11 @@ export default function UpdateSettingTracking(props: {
                     {jumlahList.map((num) => (
                       <div key={num} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(num)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(num) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, num]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== num);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), num]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== num);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
diff --git a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-detail-form.tsx b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-detail-form.tsx
index fb115b11..932bc1f4 100644
--- a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-detail-form.tsx
+++ b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-detail-form.tsx
@@ -67,11 +67,11 @@ export default function DetailSettingTracking() {
                     {wilayahList.map((item) => (
                       <div key={item.id} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(item.id)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(item.id) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, item.id]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== item.id);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), item.id]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== item.id);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
diff --git a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-form.tsx b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-form.tsx
index 50c57f60..addbde9b 100644
--- a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-form.tsx
+++ b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-form.tsx
@@ -67,11 +67,11 @@ export default function CreateSettingTracking() {
                     {wilayahList.map((item) => (
                       <div key={item.id} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(item.id)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(item.id) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, item.id]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== item.id);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), item.id]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== item.id);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />
diff --git a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-update-form.tsx b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-update-form.tsx
index 621bf378..ee260bc4 100644
--- a/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-update-form.tsx
+++ b/components/form/media-tracking/setting-tracking-update-form.tsx
@@ -67,11 +67,11 @@ export default function UpdateSettingTracking() {
                     {wilayahList.map((item) => (
                       <div key={item.id} className="flex items-center gap-2">
                         <Checkbox
-                          checked={field.value.includes(item.id)}
+                          checked={field.value?.includes(item.id) ?? false}
                           onCheckedChange={(checked) => {
                             const updated = checked
-                              ? [...field.value, item.id]
-                              : field.value.filter((val) => val !== item.id);
+                              ? [...(field.value ?? []), item.id]
+                              : (field.value ?? []).filter((val) => val !== item.id);
                             field.onChange(updated);
                           }}
                         />